Maarten Paes, Ole Romeny and the Road Without Indigenous Blood: Indonesia Is Rewriting ASEAN Football
core_answer: Maarten Paes and Ole Romeny are legally eligible to represent Indonesia because they passed two independent gates: Indonesian Citizenship Law No. 12/2006 Article 20 (parliamentary naturalization on state-interest grounds) and FIFA's RGAS substantial-connection criterion (a biological grandparent born on Indonesian territory). Neither gate requires indigenous ethnicity, so the press's 'legal loophole' framing is factually overstated.
key_facts: Maarten Paes, born 1998, is a Dutch goalkeeper of Indonesian descent; FIFA approved his Netherlands-to-Indonesia federation transfer in August 2024.; Ole Romeny, born 2000, is a Dutch forward; he took his Indonesian citizenship oath in February 2025 after DPR approval under Law No. 12/2006 Article 20.; Both players qualify via a grandparent born in the Dutch East Indies, meeting FIFA's substantial-connection birthplace criterion in the RGAS regulations.; Neither player has a parent or grandparent of indigenous Indonesian ethnicity — the eligibility rule is administrative, not ethnic.; Paes and Romeny occupy the two highest-leverage positions on the pitch: goalkeeper and centre-forward.; The eligible diaspora pool (Indo-Dutch blijvers descendants) is historically finite, making the strategy non-renewable.
source_attribution: Kompas (Indonesian national daily) reporting on the PSSI naturalization cases of Maarten Paes (April/August 2024) and Ole Romeny (February 2025); FIFA Regulations Governing the Application of the FIFA Statutes (RGAS) on eligibility; Indonesian Citizenship Law No. 12/2006. | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn
related_qa: question: Does naturalization give Indonesia an unfair advantage over Vietnam in ASEAN competition?, answer: It gives Indonesia a short-term structural edge in talent depth, but the eligible Indo-Dutch diaspora pool is historically finite, so the advantage is time-limited and cannot substitute for youth development.; question: Did Maarten Paes and Ole Romeny break any FIFA rules?, answer: No — both cleared FIFA's substantial-connection criterion via grandparent birthplace, and Paes's U21 Netherlands caps were resolved through a formally approved change of association.; question: Why can't Vietnam replicate Indonesia's naturalization model?, answer: Vietnam's colonial-era French-diaspora football pipeline is far thinner than Indonesia's Indo-Dutch professional network, making the model historically non-transferable.
The press conference in Jakarta took place in February 2026, moments after Ole Romeny signed his oath of Indonesian citizenship. A Kompas reporter stood up and asked bluntly: if these two players do not have a single drop of indigenous blood, why do they wear the Garuda shirt? The room went heavy for two seconds. The PSSI president answered with one sentence: they are Indonesian under the law, and the law does not require indigenous heritage.
I watched that clip again from Kuala Lumpur over a patchy connection. The Kompas question was not the first, and certainly not the last. But it marked a moment Southeast Asian football had never faced before: for the first time, a national team in the region was openly building its spine around players with brand-new passports and old colonial bloodlines.

The striking thing is not that Indonesia naturalizes players — that has been happening for years. The striking thing is that they naturalized exactly the two highest-leverage positions on the pitch: goalkeeper and centre-forward. A good goalkeeper can rescue a disjointed back line. A good centre-forward can turn a draw into a win. Indonesia is buying precisely where goals and defeats are decided.
Context: a wave that is not accidental
Maarten Paes was born in 2026, a Dutch goalkeeper of Indonesian descent, once capped by the Netherlands U21 and a veteran of the Eredivisie. In April 2026, he completed his federation switch from the Netherlands to Indonesia. In August 2026, FIFA formally approved it, adding him to Indonesia's national-team roster. Ole Romeny was born in 2026, a Dutch forward of Indonesian descent who played for NEC Nijmegen and FC Emmen. In February 2026 he took his citizenship oath in Jakarta after Indonesia's House of Representatives approved his naturalization under Law No. 12/2026, Article 20.
These two names do not stand alone. They sit inside a larger wave that includes Haye, Verdonk and Diks — other players of Dutch-Indonesian descent. But Paes and Romeny are the two faces the Indonesian press calls 'the most prominent stars'. That is exactly why they became the focal point of the identity debate.
What sets these two cases apart from earlier naturalizations is a legal detail few noticed: neither player has a parent or grandparent who was indigenous Indonesian. Their grandparents were Dutch settlers in the Dutch East Indies before 2026 — the group known as blijvers, European settlers who stayed in the colony long-term rather than returning to the Netherlands. Their descendants hold Dutch passports and fully European blood, yet have a grandparent born on territory that is now Indonesia.
That is the entire legal basis. And that is the entire story.
Core analysis: two gates, one mechanism
When I went back through the files on Paes and Romeny, I realized they had to pass through two independent gates, and both were open.
The first gate is Indonesian citizenship law. Article 20 of Law No. 12/2026 permits naturalization on grounds of 'state interest', subject to parliamentary approval. This is a deliberate mechanism, not a loophole. It exists so the state can grant citizenship to people it deems valuable — whether or not they carry indigenous blood. Romeny walked through this gate in February 2026.
The second gate is FIFA's rules. Under the Regulations Governing the Application of the FIFA Statutes (RGAS), a player may represent a federation if a parent or biological grandparent was born on that federation's territory. This is the 'substantial connection' criterion. Paes's case was slightly more complex, because he had been capped by the Netherlands U21, requiring an additional federation transfer — approved by FIFA in August 2026. Romeny did not need that step because he never played for the Netherlands' senior youth sides.
The key point that Indonesian media repeatedly conflates into one: these two gates are wholly independent. A player can clear FIFA's gate while failing Indonesia's citizenship law, and vice versa. Paes and Romeny cleared both — meaning they are legal twice, not once.
To understand why this is a big story for Vietnam and the region, you have to look at the positions involved.
In football, the goalkeeper carries the single highest individual leverage on the pitch. A safe pair of hands can mask a disjointed defence — something national teams face constantly, since they only train a few days before each match. At national-team level, familiarity between defenders is low, the gap between two centre-backs stretches easily, and the keeper becomes the third member of the defensive line. A European-class goalkeeper is like buying insurance for the whole defensive system without buying the system itself.
The same goes for a centre-forward. I counted through several recent Indonesia matches and noticed they often finish with far fewer goals than clear chances. The problem is not the attacking system but the finisher. Romeny arrives to fill exactly that gap — not to play beautifully, but to convert.
Two positions, two investments, one goal: raise the team's floor without building a youth academy over ten years.
Contrarian angle: a 'loophole' that is not a loophole
My first-ever blog post was not about football, but about the gap between two Johor centre-backs. That taught me a habit I have kept since: when someone calls something a 'loophole', I go find the source rule to see whether it is a design flaw or a design intent.
Here, the phrase 'legal loophole' appears densely in the press. But the grandparent-birthplace criterion is not a flaw. It is a rule FIFA deliberately built. FIFA has never defined 'substantial connection' by ethnic blood — it defines it by where a player's ancestor was born. The reason is pragmatic: in a system of more than 200 member federations, an ethnic criterion cannot operate. Who verifies a drop of blood? Who defines 'enough' indigeneity? FIFA chose a marker verifiable through civil records: an ancestor's birthplace. That is an administrative choice, not an identity choice.
That leads to a conclusion Indonesian media has not been willing to state clearly: these two players did not 'exploit' the law. They walked the exact road the law drew. If anyone must explain why that road exists, it is FIFA, not PSSI.
But viewed from Indonesia's side, I ask myself a harder question: how durable is this model?
The resource lies in the blijvers community — the Dutch who stayed in the colonial Indies. That is a closed population set. It only shrinks over time; it never expands. Every year, one more cohort of people with a living grandparent and a birth certificate from the Indies disappears. By roughly 2050, the group will be nearly gone.
In other words, Indonesia is mining a non-renewable resource. They are importing quality in this cycle, but not building a production line for the next one. This is the blind spot Indonesian media — swept up in coverage of each new recruit — is ignoring.
I remember 2026, when the pandemic took away the stands and I lost my commentary contract. I spent that time remeasuring home advantage and drew one rule: when an external input changes, on-pitch behaviour changes. This is the same logic at a macro scale. When the supply of naturalizable talent dries up, the strategy must shift, and Indonesia's national team will be forced back to the academy — where they have trailed Vietnam for years.
Regional comparison: what this means for Vietnam
I grew up in England, work in Malaysia, and I know the trap of using Premier League standards to judge Southeast Asian football. The approach here must be: start from the environment — long flights, pitch quality, congested fixtures, heat — and only then talk tactics.
So I do not compare Paes to Marc-André ter Stegen. I compare him to the keepers Vietnam and Thailand currently have, under the same climate and the same intensity of competition.

In that comparison, Indonesia has just opened a gap. Vietnam has a stronger youth-development pipeline and a deeper domestic football community. But the overseas Vietnamese community with developed football careers is far thinner than the Indo-Dutch community. This is a historical difference that cannot be copied. The Netherlands left behind in Indonesia a layer of European professional players with Indies blood. France did not leave anything comparable in Vietnam — the number of French-Vietnamese playing professional football in Europe is negligible.
That is Vietnam's structural disadvantage. Not because Vietnam is weaker, but because the board was divided differently.
And this is why Indonesia becomes a direct threat: they are not competing through development effort, they are competing through import speed. In the short term, speed wins. In the long term, the story is different.
The question before the ball rolls: nothing is settled yet
Before the ball is circulated, I had already seen three decoy receivers and one real path. Here, the real path is the combination of naturalization speed and squad integration. And this is where I am not sure.
A new goalkeeper needs a shared language with the two centre-backs in front of him. A new forward needs to learn the rhythm of his midfielders' passing. These things cannot be bought with a passport. They are bought with minutes on the pitch, with repeated training sessions, with matches where both sides err and correct together.
I see PSSI moving faster than any coaching staff's capacity to integrate. This is a common failure mode in national teams naturalizing en masse: the leadership is enthusiastic while the team has not yet learned to understand itself. National-team football is not club football. At a club, you have a whole season to bond. At a national team, you have three days.
Takeaway: what to watch
Every formation is a lie when you watch from the stands; the truth lies on the grass, where the gaps move. The Paes and Romeny story does not end at the oath. It will be verified in the next World Cup qualifiers, where one shot wide by Romeny or one fumbled catch by Paes will say more than a hundred pages of paperwork.
There are things to watch in the coming months. First, whether PSSI publishes clearer naturalization criteria, or leaves public opinion to interpret on its own. Second, whether FIFA moves to tighten the grandparent-birthplace criterion now that several Southeast Asian federations have begun copying the model. Third, whether Indonesia ramps up academy investment, or treats naturalization as its main road.
The match does not truly begin when the referee blows the whistle, but when a defender decides to leave his position. Here, the position regional football must leave is the belief that a passport automatically creates a team. Indonesia has opened two legal doors. The remaining one — the dressing-room door — is still closed.
